Sunday, March 1, 2009

MAC Dupe Forum

Dupe: In the makeup world, a duplicate product. An item similar to another item from a different brand; a substitute product. Often a dupe is referred to as an inexpensive alternative to a high end item.







I'd like to devote this blog post completely to MAC dupes. Thanks to my email buddy Maria for giving me the idea. I'm going to create a link on the side of my blog so this post will always be easily accessible.

**************************

Here's how it will work- If you know of some affordable duplicates to ANY MAC products- eyeshadow, blush, foundation, lipgloss... anything... leave a comment and tell me what they are. Then I'll post them right here to this page so they'll be organized for everyone to see. (I'll be updating as often as I can.) If you don't have a Blogger account and would rather send me an email, you can do that too: beautybroadcast@hotmail.com


If the "dupe" product does not have a name-- for example if your dupe is part of a palette-- please provide a description. EXAMPLE: "the light shade in the L'oreal HIP duo in Sculpted"-- or-- "the deep brown shade in the Cover Girl Country Woods quad." Also-- I WILL post multiple dupe products for one MAC item- if you have a different suggestion from the one posted- that's ok!

*********************************

BRUSHES:

  • 134= Coastal Scents Large Paddle Face brush
  • 136= Loew Cornell Maxine's Mop 1 inch brush
  • 150= Loew Cornell XXL Brown brushes (goat hair)
  • 187= Sonia Kashuk Highlighting BrushCoastal Scents Duo Fiber Stippling Brush, Flirt! Skunk Brush,
  • 190= Loew Cornell 1 inch Filbert brush
  • 194= Loew Cornell #8 Filbert brush
  • 224= Coastal Scents Sable Blending Brush
  • 226= Coastal Scents Tapered Blending Brush, Sonia Kashuk Blending Brush (dark curvy)
  • 228= Loew Cornell Maxine's Mop 1/4 brush
  • 239= Loew Cornell Maxine's Mop 3/8 brush
  • 242= Loew Cornell Filbert 7500 C

EYELINER:

  • Fluidline in Black Track= Coastal Scents Gel Liner in True Black, L'oreal HIP Cream Liner in Black

EYESHADOW:

  • All that Glitters= NYX Champagne
  • Amber Lights= Milani Sun Goddess, NYX Golden
  • Black Tied= Milani Storm, Prestige Onyx
  • Brulee= NYX Nude
  • Carbon= NYX Black
  • Coppering= Milani Flare
  • Cork= NYX Dark Brown
  • Creme de Violet= Aromaleigh's Pure Eyes Frost Eyeshadow in Desire
  • Dementhe= Milani Clover
  • Electric Eel= Milani Atlantis
  • Guacamole= Milani Limbo lime
  • Humid= Milani Clover, Ulta Shamrock
  • Jest= Milani Peachy Peach
  • Juxt= Milani Garden Mist
  • Little Madam= Milani Illusion
  • Mulch= Milani Java Bean
  • Naked Lunch= NYX Sahara
  • Nocturnelle= Milani Shock
  • Nylon= NYX Barely There
  • Paradisco= NYX Tropical or CoverGirl Tropical Fusion Quad (orange shade)
  • Partait Amour= Milani Enchantment
  • Passionate= NYX Cherry
  • Perverted Pearl= Milani Silver Bullet
  • Pink Freeze= Milani Taffy
  • Plum Dressing= L'oreal HIP duo in Cheeky
  • Sable= Milani Java Bean
  • Satin Taupe= NYX Root Beer, NYX Iced Mocha, L'oreal HIP Duo in Sassy (taupe shade)
  • Shadowy Lady= L'oreal HIP duo in Wicked (purple side)
  • Shale= Milani Icy Plum
  • Shroom= Milani Classic Beige or Jordana's Beige
  • Sketch= Milani Marooned
  • Stars 'n' Rockets= Milani Shock
  • Steamy= Milani Clover
  • Sumptuous Olive= Milani Antiqued Gold
  • Vanilla= Milani Snow Frost, Cover Girl single in French Vanilla
  • Vellum= Milani Moonlight
  • Wedge= L'oreal HIP duo in Shady
  • Woodwinked= Milani Golden Bronze, L'oreal HIP duo in Wicked (brown side)

  • Mineralized Eyeshadow Duo in Two to Glow= L'oreal HIP Duo in Flare

FOUNDATION:

  • Studio Fix Fluid= Revlon Colorstay

LIP BALM:

  • GENERAL: MAC Tendertones= L'oreal HIP Jelly Balm

LIPSTICK:

  • Creme d'Nude= Revlon Matte Lipstick in Nude Attitude
  • Myth= Revlon Matte Lipstick in Nude Attitude
  • Viva Glam V= NYC Cafe

PAINT:

  • Bare Canvas= L'oreal HIP Paint in Secretive

PAINT POTS:

  • Blackground= Mad Minerals Cream Shadow in Carbon
  • Indianwood= Mad Minerals Cream Shadow in Bronze Frost
  • Painterly= Mad Minerals Cream Shadow in Bare Necessity
  • Rubenesque= Mad Minerals Cream Shadow in Apricot Frost

PALETTES:

  • MAC Palettes= Coastal Scents 4 piece & 15 piece palettes (hold same size pan), also http://www.starsmakeuphaven.com/ has empty palettes that hold 15 and 28 shadows

PIGMENTS:

  • Antique Gold= Splash eye sparkles in Caribbean Bronze
  • Golden Lemon= Splash eye sparkles in Golden Beach
  • Pink Bronze= Pure Luxe in Fresh
  • Vanilla= Pure Luxe in Copper Aura

PLEASE READ! Disclaimer--The recommendations posted to this blog are not my own. They are the ideas of others who view this blog. Please do not hold me personally responsible for any duplicate products that you do not like. I trust that those who offer recommendations have also TRIED the MAC item they're comparing it to, and legitimately believe they are offering a true duplicate product.

47 comments:

lexy said...

I have no mac so i cant say any dupes, but i had to write and tell u how excited i am THANK U SO MUCH FOR THIS. u rock emily

StardustSteph said...

This is fabulous!!! The MAC store I have here is so tiny and it's full of people. It's so confusing to go around, and a lot of times I just don't even want to bother with it all, so this is so helpful! Thank you for this :).

PatriciaErin said...

MAC Amber Lights = Milani Sun Goddess
MAC Black Tied = Milani Storm
MAC Coppering = Milani Flare
MAC Dementhe, Steamy, Humid = Milani Clover
MAC Electric Eel = Milani Atlantis
MAC Guacamole = Milani Limbo Lime
MAC Jest = Milani Peachy Peach
MAC Little Madame = Milani Illusion
MAC Mulch, Sable = Milani Java Bean
MAC Parfait Amour = Milani Enchantment
MAC Perverted Pearl = Milani Silver Bullet
MAC Pink Freeze = Milani Taffy
MAC Shale = Milani Icy Plum
MAC Silver Pigment = Milani Mercury
MAC Sketch = Milani Marooned
MAC Sumptuous Olive = Milani Antiqued Gold
MAC Vanilla = Milani Snow Frost
MAC Vellum = Milani Moonlight
MAC Woodwinked = Milani Golden Bronze

beautyblog said...

I guess a lot of Milani eyeshadows are pretty good! Do you have a review of the ones you've tried?

Thanks!

kitten1711 said...

I would suggest anyone who is after MAC dupes checking out www.silknaturals.com - this is a mineral make up company who have produced a tonne of high end brand dupes (incl Bobbi Brown and Nars), not just MAC.

They have a section on the site menu bar for 'dupes/clones' but you can also type in the MAC product name in the search box and it will bring up their equivalent if they have created one (or type in MAC to see everything they have duped so far).

They have covered lipsticks (incl 2 different ones from the Viva Glam range, Utterley Frivilous from the Fafi collection), shadows, blush, MSFs (incl New Vegas, Petticoat & Global Glow) etc.

The prices are great in comparison to MAC (and samples are available for a dollar or so each), delivery is very quick (I live in the UK and delivery is usually within the week); plus they have a gift with purchase for spending over $10, plus a free eye shadow of your choice for every $30 (or is it $25?) you spend.

They also have a 'wish list' message board on the forum and if enough people request an item generally they will copy it, which is great for LE products.

I am not affiliated with them in anyway, just a very happy shopper who has purchased from them on numerous occassions.

PS MAD Minerals (www.madminerals.org) do some really great Indelible Creme Eye Shadows which are almost identical to MAC Paintpots (they are smaller, but way cheaper) - Bare Necessity is incredibly similar to MACs Painterly, and Apricot Frost is a dead ringer for Rubenesque).

HTH!

Txx

CHARLOTTE said...

MAC CARBON---NYX BLACK!!

emilynoel83 said...

OMG you guys are awesome!!! Keep the suggestions coming- also- on the right hand sidebar there is a special link so you can keep checking back directly on this blog post. :)

nhuhong said...

MAC Brush dupes:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D9lPfKzQAXE

Enjoy! :)

Blissful Nikki said...

This is so great!

I have a couple of dupes for you! :)

Paint pots:
Indianwood= Mad Minerals Cream Shadow in Bronze Frost

Blackground= Mad Minerals Cream Shadow in Carbon

pouneh said...

this is a great idea Emily...i discovered Sigma line of brushes they even have the same numbers as the MAC brushes...their collection is not complete but a good place to start
http://www.sigmamakeup.com/products.html

EnKoreMakeup on youtube has reviews of this line

paintedFACEmakeup said...

MAC Viva Glam V (Five) - N.Y.C. Cafe

Viva Glam V has just a hint more pinkness to it, but it is such a small amount it is hardly noticeable, if at all.

$14 vs. $1-2

Maggie said...

For MACs Creme de Violet, I like Aromaleigh's Pure Eyes Frost Eyeshadow in Desire:
http://www.aromaleigh.com/pueynafrmiey.html

Stacy said...

I actually just bought my first shadestick from Mac and compared it to my eyeshadow stick from Elfs studio line and i find it comparable as in texture and coverage and everything. The main difference was that my shadestick is royal hue *purple* and my shadow stick from elf is in the smoke and black. I think the sticks are a great dupe if you want something like that.

emilynoel83 said...

hey guys- please make sure you tell me if the product you suggest is a lipstick, lipgloss, shadow, paint pot etc- I actually am not that familiar with many of the products and i want to make sure i put it in the right category. thanks!

mahakhan said...
This post has been removed by the author.
mahakhan said...

Mac Dupes in "Milani SINGLES"

I personally don't like Milani Runway Eye shadows, some of the Runway singles are good though! But I love Regular Singles Eye Shadows!I have all 12 Now!

Milani Offers "12-single shades"They fits in Mac Pro-Palette and Elf Empty Palette.

Mac*************Milani
Juxt------Garden Mist
Humid/Dementhe/Steamy------Clover
Little Madama-----Illusion
Mulch/Sable------Java Bean
Woodwinked------Golden Bronze
Star n Rockets/Nocturnelle----Shock
Coppering------Flare
Electric Eel-----Atlantis
Amber Lights----Sun Goddess
Black Tied-----Storm

?????------Blue Ice(Very pretty shade)
?????--------Sheer Sand(Good highlight shade)

That's all 12 lovely Shades

CHARLOTTE said...

MAC E\S NAKED LUNCH---NYX SAHARA
SHROOM---MILANI CLASSIC BEIGE OR
JORDANA'S BEIGE

MAC BRUSHES:
219--LOEW CORNELL, DOME BRUSH MEDIUM #272, GREEN HANDLES SMALL
MAC 224 OR 228- L.C. AMM SERIES MOP ROUND 1\4
MAC 242- L.C. FILBERT 7500C
239--L.C. L.C MAXINE MOP #270 IN 3\8
134 OR 136--L.C MAXINE MOP #270 IN 1"
194--AMERICAN PAINTER #4500 SIZE 6 FILBERT

~Melissa~ said...

Thank you so much for putting up these brushes!!! I am going to get them!!!!

lucy said...

MAC Satin Taupe = taupe side of L'Oreal Hip Duo "Sassy"

OrganicWallabee said...

Does anyone know of a dupe for MAC Print eyeshadow? Would be appreciated and thanks!

Share said...

Sonia Kashuk Hilighting Brush is literally the closest dupe to the #187 that you will find. I compared both of them side by side.

The Flirt brush is no where near being like the 187, and the coastal scents brush isn't the best in quality.

dowabie said...

I have an eyeshadow by prestige called onyx and it's very similar to stately black from the hello kitty collection, it's also similar to black tide.

CHARLOTTE said...
This post has been removed by the author.
CHARLOTTE said...

I'm looking for some Dupes in Covergirl or Revlon???? Cause I can't find any of the Milani singles where I live and I just came back from Shreveport, LA and they don't have them either. And I can't find online where to buy them!!! HELP PLEASE.

Victoria said...

I don't have either of these e/s but on makeupalley they say Sally Girl's Champagene is a dupe of MAC's Vanilla. I don't know how close it actually is because I'm assuming the Sally Girl is a shimmer and vanilla is a matte(or satin?)

Victoria said...

I saw on MUA that ELF custom eyes in sage is a dupe for sumptuous olive...just passing info along

MoonbeamBeauty said...

I'm actually doing a feature like this on my youtube channel, but not doing exclusively MAC dupes. Here's a couple shadow dupes for you:

MAC Parrot= L'oreal Hip duo in Showy (teal shimmer side).
MAC Satin Taupe= Ulta Mystique.

MakeupByBrenda said...

This is a dupe on a nailpolish. MAC's "On the Prowl" nailpolish that came out with the Hello Kitty collection. You can find a great dupe at Wal-Mart the brand is Pure Ice and the color is "Kiss Me Here" its $2. :-)

Genabee6 said...

Thanks so much for this!! Here's my contribution!

Just bought Satin Taupe today and got it home to realize that in my 26 Shadow/Blush Combo Palette from Coastal Scents, there is a color in there exactly the same to Satin Taupe.

If you're looking at the palette, it's very last shadow on the bottom right. I swatched them and I couldn't tell the difference!

Taking Satin Taupe back tomorrow for a refund!
-Jenn

queenbbeee said...

I love this site....

The ELF compact, is a great dupe for MACs empty quad. It is magnetic and MAC NYX ELF and many more shadows will all fit in it. Also, ELF has a mineral eye shadow called "socialite" that is almost the exact same color as "Sweet Siena" pigment from MAC, but it is only $3.00... YEAH!!! The other ELF mineral shadows are also very pretty, there may be other dupes in the ELF collection I just dont have many MAC pigments to compare them with. Hope this helps!

Stay Beautiful - Beauty Queens
-queenbbeee

beautyblog said...

I don't know if anyone has posted this yet, but Enkore did a video about Coastal Scents Hot Pots dupes.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uXj5KYkw58g

Here's the list:
Color comparison to MAC (recap)
S01 - Juxt, Lustreleaf, Aquavert
S02 - Brill (LE)
S03 - Dreammaker (LE)
S04 - Zonk Bleu! (LE)
S05 - Patina
S06 - Plum Dressing
S07 - Solar White (LE)
S08 - Purple Haze
S09 - Honeylust
S10 - Sumptious Olive
S11 - Kelly
S12 - Freshwater
S13 - Trax
S14 - Contrast
S15 - Paradisco
S16 - Nocturnelle
S17 - Cranberry
S18 - Bitter
S19 - Parfait
S20 - Vibrant Grape (pro)
S21 - Romping
S22 - Brick (pro)
S23 - Deep Thruth
S24 - Shimmermoss
S25 - Gulf Stream
S26 - Electra
S27 - Print
S28 - Sketch
S29 - Rye
S30 - Twinks
S31 - Pink Papillon
S32 - Say Yeah
S33 - Texture
S34 - Bold & Brazen
S35 - Satin Taupe
S36 - Amber Lights
S37 - Retrospeck
S38 - Haux with glitters

B01 - Stomp e/s or Slave to Love Blush
B02 - Dirty Plum PRO Blush
B03 - Pinch Me
B04 - Melba
B05 - Sweet As Cocoa

beautyblog said...

Oh... AND!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uZJ9ToZtv78

Color Comparison to MAC (Recap)
M01 - Casa Blanca (LE)
M02 - Kelly (pro)
M03 - Lime (pro)
M04 - Bamboo
M05 - Meadow (LE)
M06 - Signed, Sealed (Matte2)
M07 - Soft Brown
M08 - Plum Dressing
M09 - Vanilla
M10 - Samoa Silk
M11 - Fountainbleu
M12 - Aqua (pro)
M13 - Melton Mauve
M14 - Saddle
M15 - Cobalt (pro)
M16 - Charcoal Brown
M17 - Meet The Fleet (LE)
M18 - Azalea (pro blush)
M19 - Gesso
M20 - Brule
M21 - Haux
M22 - Handwritten (Matte2) & Dark Edge (LE)
M23 - Typographic

emilieb84 said...

MAC Dupe=paint pot
- Mac Paint pot in Bare Study = Mad Minerals in Nude Frost

Narita said...

For Charlotte: Try Walgreens.com. They have all Milani e/s.

Jewels said...

If anyone is looking for an exact dupe for Mac's Vanilla pigment, GET the Loreal Hip High Intensity pigment in "Restless". I compared these two & I swear they are identical. I couldn't even tell them apart!
Thank you so much Emily, & also to everybody who posts on this blog. Your suggestions are so helpful :)

Nicolesid1 said...

Mac Cranberry - L'oreal HiP light red in the Cheeky

Malena Belle said...

This list is amazing!! what a genius idea to create a running blog post like this. I will be sure to keep tabs on it when I make my shopping lists from now on :-)

Liz KS said...

Thank you so much for having this forum. I cannot afford MAC and having the dupes is awesome! What a great idea!!

dannimag said...

Revlon Super Lustrous gloss in Life's a Peach is a dupe of MAC's Enchantress lipglass.

hillbean@optonline.net said...

where can i find milani eyeshadow? I live in ny and cvs / target only have the quads no singles. I have been searching for java bean. I had to break down and buy mac mulch, please help!
Thanks everyone

Jewels said...

You can find Milani eyeshadows at Meijer, Walmart, Walgreens & also Rite Aide. Hope that helps! :)

Sasakichild001 said...

Hey Emily,
I'm not sure if anyone has posted this yet, but here's a link to an AMAZING list of dupes:
http://www.longhaircareforum.com/forums/showthread.php?t=338321

Hope you all enjoy!

bmfirkus said...

MAC Beauty Marked

=

Dark color of L'Oreal HIP duo in "Sculpted"

I actually prefer this shadow to the MAC shadow.

ttlyblonde1230 said...

Does anyone know of a dupe for MAC lipstick in Captive?? I am in LOVE with that color for fall.

Thanks!

MakeUpMadeEasy said...

What a fabulous idea i will make a point of checking this area of your blog for duplicates

Jessica said...

another dupe for mac's satin taupe is the ELF custom eye's shadow in Moondust (the eyeshadow that you can put into a pallet)

Donigirl said...

Does anyone know the dupe for MAC's Rice Paper?? Thanks!